Death row inmate Tommy Zeigler gets all-clear for DNA testing

ORLANDO — Demise row inmate Tommy Zeigler has received his crusade for screening.

Days before the 47th anniversary of the Christmas Eve quadruple murder that sent him to prison, an Orlando circuit judge signed an order enabling his crew to take a look at all of the proof in his case for DNA.

It’s the consequence he’s been in search of for just about two many years, irrespective of vehement opposition from major Florida prosecutors. Zeigler hopes it is a opportunity to obvious his identify.

The proof incorporates by no means-right before-examined fingernail clippings, guns and outfits of all of the victims — who have been Zeigler’s spouse, in-regulations and another man at his family’s household furniture retail store exterior Orlando.

The Tampa Bay Times explored his situation in a 2018 series and podcast called Blood and Reality.

Related: Go through the job: Blood and Reality | Could DNA verify him harmless? Florida does not want to know

“This is a victory for Tommy,” reported David Michaeli, a person of Zeigler’s New York lawyers, who not long ago went to stop by Zeigler on dying row.

The 77-year-outdated has struggled with coronary heart and respiratory challenges in modern yrs, specially considering that he contracted the coronavirus in 2020. He’s identified for performing exercises with miles of jogging and pushups in his smaller cell.

“He’s seeking almost everything he can to appear right after himself,” Michaeli claimed. “But you can only do so a lot with pushups.”

Letters from Tommy Zeigler to Lynn-Marie Carty line the cabinets of her residing space. Carty has supported Zeigler as a personal investigator for a lot more than a decade.

Zeigler’s New York lawyers are having to pay for the screening, which will be executed by Forensic Analytical Crime Laboratory centered in Hayward, California. Zeigler’s attorneys say the proof, collected from the Zeigler home furniture retail store in Winter Back garden, could be sent to the lab in the following 30 times.

Dozens and dozens of parts of proof from the December 1975 criminal offense will be released and analyzed for the initial time.

In accordance to its site, the California lab has carried out 150 put up-conviction investigations, main to the exoneration of 50 folks who had been wrongly convicted, like quite a few sentenced to dying.

It is also testing proof in the situation of Henry Sireci, convicted in the 1975 murder of an Orlando employed motor vehicle great deal operator. Sireci received the appropriate to examination his evidence this summer months.

A 38-caliber bullet casing in front of the Zeigler furniture store in Winter Garden. Zeigler was convicted of the murders of his wife, in-laws and another man in his furniture store on Christmas Eve 1975.
A 38-caliber bullet casing in entrance of the Zeigler home furniture keep in Winter season Yard. Zeigler was convicted of the murders of his spouse, in-rules and another guy in his furnishings retail store on Xmas Eve 1975.
Looking for real-time news alerts?

Wanting for actual-time information alerts?

Subscribe to our cost-free Breaking Information publication

You’ll acquire updates on important difficulties and occasions in Tampa Bay and past as they happen.

You are all signed up!

Want additional of our cost-free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Investigate all your solutions

Zeigler has asked 50 percent a dozen times all through the last 19 yrs to evaluate the proof. But he normally satisfied with rejection till the election of Ninth Judicial Circuit Condition Attorney Monique H. Worrell, who experienced begun the office’s conviction integrity unit. Worrell, one of just a pair progressive condition lawyers in Florida, signed agreements with Zeigler and Sireci to conduct the DNA testing months after she took place of work in 2020.

Zeigler’s legal professionals had in the beginning sought early DNA screening in 1994. The testing was granted in 2001, and the success appeared to help his claim of innocence. Forensic checks on four smaller squares of Zeigler’s plaid trousers and corduroy shirt failed to detect his murdered family members’ blood.

When Zeigler’s legal professionals questioned, starting in 2003, to further more examine Zeigler’s outfit and later on to use contact DNA assessments, Florida prosecutors and judges refused. They reported the testing would not automatically exonerate Zeigler, as Florida’s 2001 DNA testing law mandated. They pointed to witnesses, which include Zeigler’s handyman, who explained to jurors that Zeigler tried using to shoot him.

But Zeigler’s New York lawyers, Dennis Tracey and Michaeli, noticed that if he had murdered four people today, their blood really should be on his clothes. His father-in-law’s fingernail clippings have hardly ever been analyzed, even while the minister from Georgia fought with another person in the dim shop.

On Monday, Circuit Choose Patricia L. Stowbridge also refused a request by Lawyer Common Ashley Moody’s place of work to hold off on her decision for a thirty day period though Moody’s attorneys come to a decision no matter whether to enchantment. Stowbridge even requested if she had the authority to strike a see of attractiveness, which she made a decision not to do. Moody’s office environment could attractiveness the final decision to enable testing, but the evidence will be released for testing no issue what.

A spokesperson for Moody explained Monday that her workplace was reviewing the purchase.

“Tommy is guardedly optimistic,” said Michaeli outside the house the courtroom Monday. “Tommy knows from 47 a long time of residing incarcerated in a 6-by-9 cell that just about anything can go completely wrong. He’s learned to mood his pleasure.”